Q: When is the best time for my baby's cleft foot surgery? One surgeon says 6 months, another says 1 year.

This post is a dramatization of a question and answer session experienced by our actual medical reviewers. Please note that this content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional for any health concerns or before making any decisions related to your health or treatment.

Question: My 8-week-old son was born with a mild case of cleft foot on one foot. The surgery would involve moving his big toe to close the gap. We've consulted with two specialists, an orthopedic surgeon and a plastic surgeon, at a major children's hospital. The orthopedic surgeon recommended waiting until after he is a year old due to anesthesia risks. However, the plastic surgeon suggested surgery between 6-8 months, as it would be easier for him to heal before he starts walking. I'm unsure which advice to follow and we are considering getting a third opinion from another leading children's hospital. What should we do?

Answer: Tough decision. It's a classic "surgeon vs. anesthesiologist" debate. This isn't about right versus wrong; it's a common medical scenario involving a balance of competing, valid priorities. You will likely make your decision based on the strengths of each team and the severity of your child's case. For example, if a team has extensive experience with anesthesia in 6-8 month-olds, you might opt for earlier surgery. If a team has a long track record of successful outcomes with surgery after one year, they will likely recommend that.

Each team is likely considering what they believe will bring the best result for your child. The good news is that the case is mild (which means both are viable options, thankfully. Sometimes patients don't get a choice).

For extra peace of mind and clear guidance when tracking your child's symptoms, the FeverCoach app is always there to help.

https://fevercoach.us