Tylenol During Pregnancy and Autism: Separating Fact from Fiction

By Dr. Sam Ahn, MD (Family Medicine Specialist, Medical Contents Director of MoDoc AI) | September 23, 2025

Recent headlines linking acetaminophen (Tylenol) use during pregnancy to autism spectrum disorder have understandably caused concern among parents and expectant mothers across the United States.

Many of you may be questioning past decisions about using Tylenol during pregnancy or when treating your child's fever. As a family physician, I want to address these concerns with the most current scientific evidence and provide clear, actionable guidance.

The Bottom Line: What 2.48 Million Children Tell Us

Let me start with the key finding: A comprehensive Swedish study following 2.48 million children found no causal link between acetaminophen use and autism spectrum disorder. When researchers compared siblings within the same families—effectively controlling for genetic and environmental factors—there was no association between prenatal acetaminophen exposure and autism development. Similar findings emerged from a Japanese cohort study of over 200,000 participants. These represent the most robust scientific evidence available to date.

Important Medical Context

Acetaminophen has been safely used for over 70 years and remains the first-line analgesic and antipyretic recommended for pregnant women and children by major medical organizations including the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), and the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine (SMFM).

Current Regulatory Status

While the FDA has initiated communications with healthcare providers and is reviewing product labeling, all major medical societies maintain their existing recommendations. ACOG explicitly states that "extensive research demonstrates acetaminophen's important and safe role in maternal healthcare."

Understanding the Controversy: Why These Claims Emerged

The Correlation vs. Causation Trap

Consider this analogy: Ice cream sales and shark attacks both increase during summer months. Does ice cream attract sharks? Of course not. Warm weather drives people to both beaches and ice cream shops. This illustrates the critical distinction between correlation (two things occurring together) and causation (one thing causing another). The acetaminophen-autism debate suffers from this same logical fallacy.

Identifying the Real Factors

When pregnant women take acetaminophen, it's typically to treat fever or pain—symptoms of underlying conditions. Research suggests that the underlying illness itself (such as influenza or other infections), not the medication, may influence neurodevelopmental outcomes.

Additionally, recall bias plays a significant role. Parents of children diagnosed with autism often scrutinize every aspect of pregnancy, remembering medication use more vividly due to understandable concerns about causation. Parents of neurotypical children may not recall routine medication use from years ago with the same clarity.

The Real Risks: What Science Actually Shows

Documented Risks of Untreated Fever in Pregnancy:

• First-trimester fever above 101°F (38.3°C): Associated with increased risk of neural tube defects

• Prolonged high fever: Linked to preterm birth and pregnancy loss

• Untreated severe pain: Stress hormones can negatively impact fetal development

• Untreated bacterial infections: Risk of progression to sepsis

ACOG emphasizes that "the risks of untreated fever significantly outweigh the theoretical risks of appropriate acetaminophen use." Any advice to "tough it out" without treatment is not only misguided but potentially dangerous.

Evidence-Based Guidelines for Expectant Mothers

Key Recommendations:

Don't panic about past use. The medical consensus continues to support acetaminophen as safe when used appropriately during pregnancy.

Consult your healthcare provider. For fever during pregnancy, always contact your obstetrician rather than self-treating. They can provide personalized guidance based on your specific situation.

Know when to seek immediate care:

• Fever above 102°F (39°C) unresponsive to medication

• Signs of preterm labor or decreased fetal movement

• Inability to maintain hydration or severe malaise

Practical Approach to Fever Management:

For after-hours mild symptoms: Take acetaminophen as directed and follow up with your provider the next day

For concerning symptoms: Seek immediate evaluation at an emergency department or urgent care facility

Moving Forward with Confidence

Medical science evolves through rigorous research and careful analysis. While no medication is without theoretical risk, the current body of evidence—including studies of millions of children—does not support a causal relationship between appropriate acetaminophen use and autism spectrum disorder.

The greater risk lies in allowing fear to prevent necessary treatment. Untreated fever and pain during pregnancy pose documented risks to both mother and baby. Work with your healthcare team to make informed decisions based on scientific evidence rather than speculation.

---------------------------

Dr. Sam Ahn is a board-certified family medicine physician and medical advisor for MoDoc AI's FeverCoach. This article is for educational purposes and does not replace professional medical advice.